Job's Daughters Website Battle


This one requires a little background. I am the webmaster for a Masonic youth group's Virginia website. I'm happy to do this, and I get mostly praise for all the hard work I do on it, but one man has emailed me since the website began only to remind me that he is in charge, and that I have to ask his permission to put anything on the website.

For those of you not familiar with Job's Daughters, I've included a glossary of terms. Click on a term to learn its definition.


From: Kamala
To: Update List

Sent: Wednesday, November 05, 2003 11:03 PM
Subject: Jobie Updates for Nov. 5

Hi everyone,

Wanted to let you know about a few updates...

- The pictures from Bethel 22's Halloween Party are up at http://www.iojdva.org/pics.htm (thanks Mom Mona for sending those).

- Bethel 52 is hosting a Fall Harvest Soup and Bread Dinner Saturday, Nov. 8. More info can be found at http://www.iojdva.org/pdf/soupbreaddinner.pdf and http://www.iojdva.org/calendar.htm

- It's time to start thinking about Leadership again. There will be a T-shirt design contest and a contest to come up with the theme for Leadership 2004. All information can be found at http://www.iojdva.org/pdf/Leadership2004info.pdf

Hope everyone had a wonderful Halloween!

Jobie love,
Kamala

webmaster
iojdva.org



From: Hank
To: Kamala
Cc: Mary; Major [the Grand Guardian and Associate Grand Guardian, the two "govenors" of Virginia's Job's Daughters]
Sent: Thursday, November 06, 2003 1:08 PM
Subject: RE: Jobie Updates for Nov. 5

Kamala,

I don’t remember getting anything to review for posting to the website. Did Mom Mary approve these items?

I must reinteratre the procedure is that before anything is posted to the website it is to be approved by Grand Guardian Council. I have not looked at the items and am sure they are fine. However, we have a procedure in place and it should be followed.

Hank


From: Kamala Hirsch
To: Hank
Cc: Mary, Major
Sent: Thursday, November 06, 2003 10:08 PM
Subject: Re: Jobie Updates for Nov. 5

Hank,

You're right, I should have emailed you about these updates first, and I'm sorry. But is there any content I can post without waiting for approval? Let me elaborate:

What is the protocol for reading an announcement in a meeting? Does the chairperson need the approval of Mary, Major and Pat before it can be read in the meeting? If the chairperson emails me what is to be read in the bethel, is it safe to include that on the website?

One of my concerns, and perhaps the underlying reason I simply post most appropriate information I'm sent, is turnaround time. Council members have emailed me information about events happening less than a week away--but only after sending you an email with the same information, and finding out you are out of town. Of course they want people to know that they are having said event, but they are afraid that if they wait much longer the information won't get posted on the website in time. The sooner the information is available, the more people will see it.

If the GGC wants a static website with generic information that doesn't change, that's fine. Let me know and I can change it and essentially be done with it. But I feel the internet's greatest strength over other communication channels is its ability to remain current and be updated almost instantaneously, and in turn be immensely more useful. If all information has to go through a series of checkpoints before it can be uploaded for all to read, how current can it be?

I understand that everyone is busy and how often emails can get lost or forgotten in the Inbox, if not addressed immediately. I know that if I don't sit down and take care of updates for the website as soon as I get them, I'm likely to forget about them until I sort through my Inbox days or even weeks later--and by that time, events could have come and gone. I'm sure everyone is well aware (and I learned first-hand when we were trying to get the ball rolling on the website), sometimes sending emails can be a dead end. I have emailed adults requesting something in particular, never to hear from them again. Should I have to email the people repeatedly to get an answer before posting something to the website (or decide to not include it at all)?

Also, does the information have to come directly TO me FROM either you, Mary, Major, or Pat? I am on Bethel 52's adult mailing list, and so I get the emails Mary sends to all bethel guardians. I then take any information that is useful and post it on the website (such as rescheduled GVs). Is that okay? It would take less time, and Mary wouldn't have to worry about thinking to email me later with the same information.

What about pictures? Do I need approval for those as well? And what about the captions?

Job's Daughters has played a very important part in my life since I was initiated in 1992, and I'm happy to help in any way I can. I'm grateful to have the opportunity to help in such a unique way, and I think that Virginia's website is stronger because a former jobie is the webmaster, instead of a "relative" outsider. On top of my own personal interest in maintaining the website, I'm thrilled to hear that everyone else loves it too.

With that in mind, maybe we should go over the approval procedure (and maybe consider revising some of the rules now that the site is in full swing) before I make any additional updates. I understand that the GGC is ultimately responsible for any content on the website, but I would NEVER post anything I felt was inappropriate in any way. In all honesty, the reason I started sending the email updates was so I could get the information up as soon as possible, and also let you know what the updates were (and on the off chance there were any problems/corrections/issues, you could let me know and I could take care of them immediately).

Once I'm completely clear on the rules, maybe we should spread the word to everyone else as well. I can post the rules on the website, and an email can be sent out to all bethel guardians as a reminder. I have lots of other things I'd like to talk to the BGs, ABGs and GSs about to enhance the website, but they can wait.

Like all other adults involved in Job's Daughters, I have the best intentions for this. Please let me know how you'd like me to proceed in the future, because I'd like to avoid getting anyone's nose out of joint again (including my own).

Sincerely,

Kamala



Since I sent out the last email, Mary (the Grand Guardian) has called me to thank me again for all the work I've done on the website, and let me know that she thinks Hank was out of line and that he owes me an apology. I have yet to hear from Hank (apology or otherwise), but I think I made my feelings clear, and that I was not going to get his approval on every little thing, and that I think I'm competent enough to know what is appropriate and what is not.
Only thing that makes me nervous now is that the woman who will be Grand Guardian next year is Hank's wife. I guess I better enjoy my time with Mary as Grand Guardian :-)

 

Glossary

Job's Daughters (Job rhymes with robe): a Masonic youth group for girls ages 11-20 and related to a Master Mason. Go back.

Bethel: a chapter of girls. There are several throughout the state, each has a different number to help differentiate one from another. For example, Bethel 1 is in Arlington, and Bethel 42 is in Virginia Beach. Go back.

Grand Guardian Council (GGC): The adults in charge in Virginia, lead by a Grand Guardian and an Associate Grand Guardian. Go back.

Mary, Major and Pat: The Grand Guardian (Mary Strehle), Associate Grand Guardian (Major Stephenson), and Grand Guardian Secretary (Patricia Rary), the three most important and active adults in Virginia's Job's Daughters day-to-day business. Hank Rees is the Grand Guardian Treasurer (and a Past Associate Grand Guardian), the #4 guy in the GGC. Go back.